top of page
Image by Alexander Grey
  • Hilary Sumner
  • Dec 23, 2025
  • 2 min read

Artificial intelligence has transformed how media is created, enabling machines to replicate human speech with remarkable realism. While these technologies unlock new creative and commercial possibilities, they also raise a fundamental legal question: who owns a person’s voice once it has been cloned by AI?


The Rise of Voice Cloning


Early text-to-speech tools have evolved into sophisticated AI systems capable of recreating a person’s unique vocal characteristics including tone, pitch, cadence, and accent. These tools have legitimate uses, such as improving accessibility for people with speech impairments and enabling seamless dubbing in entertainment applications. Unfortunately, this same technology can be exploited to create deepfakes, enabling impersonation that facilitates fraud and inflicts reputational harm. Because a voice is closely tied to personal identity, its replication presents serious ethical and legal concerns.


Why Copyright Law Falls Short


Traditional intellectual property law offers little protection for the human voice itself. Copyright protects recorded works, scripts, and compositions rather than the distinctive sound of a person’s voice. As a result, AI systems can generate synthetic speech that sounds identical to an individual without copying a protected recording, exploiting a significant legal gap.


The Role of the Right of Publicity


Most legal protection for vocal identity currently comes from the right of publicity, which gives individuals control over the commercial use of their name, likeness, and voice. Courts have recognized that unauthorized imitation of a distinctive voice can violate these rights, particularly in commercial contexts. Recent decisions and legislation suggests a growing recognition that a person’s voice is a form of personal property deserving protection, even after death.


Industry Response and Contractual Protections


Performers and voice actors have been especially affected. To address the risk of unauthorized AI training and voice replication, many now rely on contractual tools such as synthetic voice or AI riders. These provisions prohibit the use of recorded performances for AI purposes without explicit consent and compensation. Regulatory efforts are also emerging, including proposed U.S. legislation and the European Union’s AI Act, which aim to impose transparency and accountability requirements on AI developers.


Final Thoughts


While AI developers may own the technology, the voice itself should remain the property of the individual. As the law evolves, personality rights and targeted legislation are increasingly filling the gaps left in traditional copyright law.


 
 
 


Launching a new product or service is an exciting step for any business. But before you invest time and money into branding, marketing, and production, there is one critical task that can save you from costly legal battles and brand confusion: conducting a trademark search. Skipping this step can lead to unexpected challenges that might derail your launch or damage your reputation.



What is a Trademark Search?


A trademark search is a process of checking existing trademarks to see if your proposed product or service name, logo, or slogan is already in use or registered by someone else. This search helps identify potential conflicts that could prevent you from legally using your chosen brand elements.


The search covers databases maintained by government trademark offices, such as the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), as well as common law trademarks that might not be registered but are still protected through use.


Why a Trademark Search Matters


Avoid Legal Disputes and Costs


Trademark searches help to avoid potential infringement on someone else’s trademark rights even where such infringement is unintentional. If your product or service name is too similar to an existing trademark, the owner can file a lawsuit against you. Legal battles can be expensive, time-consuming, and damaging to your brand’s reputation.


In a recent case a food truck called itself Flaco's Taco without realizing that a restaurant with three locations in Chicago was operating under a registered trademark of the same name. CLICK HERE FOR FULL ARTICLE


Protect Your Brand Identity


Your brand name and logo are key assets that distinguish your product or service in the market. If another company uses a similar trademark, customers might confuse the two brands, diluting your brand’s value and causing lost sales.


A trademark search helps ensure your brand identity is unique and memorable. It also allows you to build strong brand recognition without the risk of overlap.


Save Time and Resources


Discovering a trademark conflict after launching your product can mean costly rebranding, redesigning packaging, and changing marketing materials. These changes can delay your product’s entry into the market and increase expenses.


By conducting a trademark search early, you can avoid these setbacks and focus your resources on growing your business.


How to Conduct a Trademark Search


Use Official Trademark Databases


Start by searching the trademark database of your country’s intellectual property office. For example, in the U.S., the USPTO’s Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS) is a free tool that allows you to search registered and pending trademarks.


Search Beyond Registered Trademarks


Not all trademarks are registered. Some businesses rely on common law rights based on actual use in commerce. To find these, search business directories, domain names, social media platforms, and industry publications.


Consider Professional Help


Trademark law can be complex. Hiring a trademark attorney or a specialized search firm can provide a thorough search and legal advice. Professionals can also help interpret search results and guide you through the registration process.


What to Do If You Find a Conflict


If your search reveals a similar or identical trademark, you have several options:


  • Choose a different name or logo to avoid conflict.

  • Contact the trademark owner to negotiate a coexistence agreement, if possible.

  • Consult a trademark attorney to explore legal options.


Ignoring conflicts can lead to serious consequences, so it’s best to address them early.


Final Thoughts


Conducting a trademark search before launching your new product or service is a smart step that protects your business from legal risks, preserves your brand identity, and saves you time and money. It helps you enter the market with confidence, knowing your brand is unique and legally secure.


 
 
 

What Is Dupe Culture?


Dupe culture involves products that closely resemble established brands in appearance, packaging, or overall presentation but are sold at a lower price. Although dupes often avoid copying exact trademarks, they can still create a similar commercial impression, attracting consumers who want the look or feel of a premium product without the cost. This trend matters because widespread dupes can dilute brand distinctiveness, confuse consumers, and weaken the value and goodwill brands work to build.


Trademark Law and Its Limits


Trademark law protects names, logos, and other identifiers to prevent consumer confusion. However, dupe culture frequently operates in legal gray areas. Many dupes use different names while mimicking packaging, color schemes, or design elements closely enough to evoke the original brand without direct infringement. Online marketplaces further complicate enforcement by enabling rapid and anonymous sales. Proving consumer confusion and enforcing rights (especially across international markets) can be challenging.



How Brands Are Responding


To combat dupe culture, brands are expanding trademark protection to cover packaging, patterns, colors, and product shapes, educating consumers about authenticity, and working with online platforms to remove misleading listings. Some brands also emphasize innovation, quality, and customer experience to differentiate themselves beyond appearance alone.


Looking Ahead


Dupe culture is unlikely to disappear, given ongoing consumer demand for affordable alternatives. Trademark law and enforcement strategies will continue to evolve, alongside greater collaboration between brands, marketplaces, and regulators. Dupe culture challenges both legal boundaries and brand strategy, forcing companies to rethink how they protect and communicate their value in an increasingly imitation-driven market.


 
 
 
SUMNER IP LAW PLLC
336 Cumberland Street
Lebanon, PA 17042
  • Facebook
FullLogo_NoBuffer.jpeg
  • LinkedIn
Ph:      717.202.5528
Fax:    717.740.2020
Email: hilary@sumneriplaw.com
bottom of page